On the journey in space, Steven wonders if he should have brought a gift for White to make a good impression, and Yellow snaps that that's not happening because turning up in Pink's ship will prove that the last six millennia are the greatest embarrassment in the history of Gem society. As Steven clumsily walks the ship out into the bay for takeoff to get a running start, Pearl comments that Pink was just as ungainly while piloting it. Garnet assures Greg that Steven will be fine, and asks him to "water" Cat Steven. Bismuth tells Steven she's not coming, advising him that he's going into the lions' den and he'll need to roar like them, and that someone has to look after the poofed Peridot and Lapis. Maheswaran noting that she can't believe she asked Connie if she's got her sword. The arrival of Pink's ship in Beach City causes people to stare, and Ronaldo to snap a photo. Everyone else figures out what the pyramids are long before Steven does, only realizing that they are the knees of Pink's legs-shaped ship after he's activated it and Bismuth tells him to turn around. Steven takes everyone to Rose's dump, where he suggests they need to start searching around the large pink "pyramids" and that it might take a while. Yellow points out that her and Blue's ships have been destroyed, but Blue wonders if Pink's ship still exists. Blue and Yellow explain that White hasn't left Homeworld in eons, so Steven resolves to go there to ask for her help personally. Pearl explains to Steven that White isn't like any other Gem, including the other Diamonds. All of the Crystal Gems are scared except for Amethyst, who's just confused. Steven asks what Yellow means by that, and she snaps back that of course she means White Diamond. It is then suggested that perhaps all four Diamonds can reverse the corruption. Yellow irately asks Steven, still thinking he's Pink, how many decent Gems she had them ruin. It takes Blue, Yellow and Steven to get Centi, or rather Nephrite, to a state where she looks like herself and can talk, but when she cheerfully asks if they've avenged Pink Diamond by destroying "Rose Quartz", all three recoil and the Gem reverts back to her corrupted state. Blue and Yellow are shocked, and Steven demands that they try to heal her. Steven, Connie and the Crystal Gems take Blue and Yellow to Centipeetle's dropship, where they introduce them to a corrupted Gem.
Something occurs to the two Diamonds: how did Pink survive the blast they intended to destroy every Gem on Earth? Steven explains as best he can about Pink/Rose giving up her physical form to create him, and that he doesn't have any of her memories Yellow assumes that Pink just has amnesia. After Yellow finds that her ship is too damaged to move and gets Blue to stop crying by noting that she can't see, she asks "Pink" why "she" didn't tell them who she was at the trial. Garnet is unhappy, since she knows Blue as a shatterer, but Bismuth points out that she's not going to hurt Steven. Steven is getting cuddled by Blue Diamond, whose Tears of Joy are affecting all the other Gems.